Magnoli Madagascar shirt

Mr WhiteMr White Posts: 21MI6 Agent
in James Bond Memorabilia, Collecting & Props
Just came across this today and thought some of you might be interested:

http://magnolic.ipower.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=21&products_id=221&osCsid=6abe887fed86e0625175810a8e3be84a

The price isn't too bad either at $150. I'll definitely be getting one.
«1

Comments

  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    GREAT find Mr. White. I find that not only very close but also closer to what I can pay. Thanks
  • A7ceA7ce Birmingham, EnglandPosts: 656MI6 Agent
    I'm sure a lot of you who missed out on the previous one because of price will be able to snap this up.
  • LOO7K OUTLOO7K OUT United KingdomPosts: 474MI6 Agent
    edited October 2008
    WTF??? How has this happened?

    Call me a financial fool, but I'll be honouring the deal I made for the run. I want the best.

    Especially as Paul, Simon, David et al have put so much work into it.

    Duncan
  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    In my eyes, this Madagascar shirt by Indy looks spot on to the screen version.
  • HalfMonk HalfHitmanHalfMonk HalfHitman USAPosts: 2,353MI6 Agent
    Youch. Didn't see that coming.
  • Asp9mmAsp9mm Over the Hills and Far Away.Posts: 7,535MI6 Agent
    cpoulos62 wrote:
    In my eyes, this Madagascar shirt by Indy looks spot on to the screen version.

    It's like comparing the Magnoli TND tie to the Turnbull & Asser version. And the pattern isn't aligned ;)
    ..................Asp9mmSIG-1-2.jpg...............
  • Roland007Roland007 United KingdomPosts: 58MI6 Agent
    Bloody hell, where did that come from ?!! Did anyone know he had this in the pipeline ?
  • avekevavekev UkPosts: 122MI6 Agent
    Looks like the 'exclusivity' has just been blown out of the water!
  • HalfMonk HalfHitmanHalfMonk HalfHitman USAPosts: 2,353MI6 Agent
    Pattern's certainly lined up in the photo.
  • LOO7K OUTLOO7K OUT United KingdomPosts: 474MI6 Agent
    avekev wrote:
    Looks like the 'exclusivity' has just been blown out of the water!

    Not as far as I'm concerned. X-(

    DC
  • Asp9mmAsp9mm Over the Hills and Far Away.Posts: 7,535MI6 Agent
    avekev wrote:
    Looks like the 'exclusivity' has just been blown out of the water!

    nah, Magnolis is just a replica, Pauls is the real deal.
    ..................Asp9mmSIG-1-2.jpg...............
  • HalfMonk HalfHitmanHalfMonk HalfHitman USAPosts: 2,353MI6 Agent
    And the thread debuts 11 months to the day after the "Madagascar Shirt - The Deal" thread does. This didn't come from left field, it drove slowly toward us from the horizon.
  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    Asp9mm wrote:
    avekev wrote:
    Looks like the 'exclusivity' has just been blown out of the water!

    nah, Magnolis is just a replica, Pauls is the real deal.

    Actually Magnoli is very reliable and represents quality products. His reproductiions are very close to perfection. ie his Armani Leather CR jacket and T&A ties. It is not fair to knock his wear.
  • avekevavekev UkPosts: 122MI6 Agent
    Sorry guys, didn't want to upset anybody. I am just as perplexed as anyone about this, as I have been following the whole Madagascar shirt affair from the beginning.
    What I meant from my 'exclusivity' comment was the fact that from the beginning, I thought the material was being keep exclusive for reasons of copyright and not to upset EON etc. All reasons that I could fully understand. Now with this Magnoli replica how does that sit with the copyright issue.
    And for the same reason I never ordered one of the original shirts, I shan't be ordering one of the replica's - I think it's horrible, But that's my opinion.
  • Coldheart96Coldheart96 Florida , USAPosts: 203MI6 Agent
    I suppose it was only a matter of time before these would show up. Anyone who browses this site would see all the discussions that have gone on about clothes, props, collectibles, etc and a savvy business person sees the potential market. Regardless, I will still honor my committment to purchase the original shirt. Gentlemen, I applaud your work on this project and stand behind you 100%.
    Bond: "Who would spend $1 million to kill me?"
    M: "Jealous husbands. Outraged chefs. Humiliated tailors. The list is endless!"
  • Asp9mmAsp9mm Over the Hills and Far Away.Posts: 7,535MI6 Agent
    cpoulos62 wrote:
    Asp9mm wrote:
    avekev wrote:
    Looks like the 'exclusivity' has just been blown out of the water!

    nah, Magnolis is just a replica, Pauls is the real deal.

    Actually Magnoli is very reliable and represents quality products. His reproductiions are very close to perfection. ie his Armani Leather CR jacket and T&A ties. It is not fair to knock his wear.

    I did not knock him in any way. This is not the original material, it is a copy. I have no problem with people buying this copy, but it is exactly that, just as his Armani replicas and Turnbull and Asser replicas are copies.

    Unfortunately though, the original material suppliers own the copyright on that particular pattern, and someone might be slightly aggressive in enforcing that copyright.
    ..................Asp9mmSIG-1-2.jpg...............
  • avekevavekev UkPosts: 122MI6 Agent
    Asp9mm wrote:
    Unfortunately though, the original material suppliers own the copyright on that particular pattern, and someone might be slightly aggressive in enforcing that copyright.

    That was the point I was trying to make in my original post
  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    edited October 2008
    Asp9mm wrote:
    cpoulos62 wrote:
    Asp9mm wrote:

    nah, Magnolis is just a replica, Pauls is the real deal.

    Actually Magnoli is very reliable and represents quality products. His reproductiions are very close to perfection. ie his Armani Leather CR jacket and T&A ties. It is not fair to knock his wear.

    I did not knock him in any way. This is not the original material, it is a copy. I have no problem with people buying this copy, but it is exactly that, just as his Armani replicas and Turnbull and Asser replicas are copies.

    Unfortunately though, the original material suppliers own the copyright on that particular pattern, and someone might be slightly aggressive in enforcing that copyright.

    Thanks for clarifying that.

    It would be nice to see some side by side pics from the 3 shirts. Magnoli's, Paul's and movie still with DC. I would like to see the differences. I am sure we have some Photoshop pros on here. Peace
  • Asp9mmAsp9mm Over the Hills and Far Away.Posts: 7,535MI6 Agent
    edited October 2008
    avekev wrote:
    Sorry guys, didn't want to upset anybody. I am just as perplexed as anyone about this, as I have been following the whole Madagascar shirt affair from the beginning.
    What I meant from my 'exclusivity' comment was the fact that from the beginning, I thought the material was being keep exclusive for reasons of copyright and not to upset EON etc. All reasons that I could fully understand. Now with this Magnoli replica how does that sit with the copyright issue.
    And for the same reason I never ordered one of the original shirts, I shan't be ordering one of the replica's - I think it's horrible, But that's my opinion.

    No problem. Whoever owns pieces of the original 'genuine' material may do as they wish with it (such as making the Maddy shirt or even boxers). Actually copying that material and offering it for sale though does breach copyright. I'm sure that this topic will go down in the annals of AJB history.

    Just to clarify the differences....

    Paul has the original material, buttons etc, access to the exact pattern and cut. And the original costumers that worked on the film making it.

    Magnolis is a copy of the original material and a copy of the pattern and cut based on film stills. Again, they both have their own markets, but it is just like comparing the Turnbull and Asser original to the Magnoli copy. Close, but with definate differences. That's why you guys always pay more for the T&A versions.
    ..................Asp9mmSIG-1-2.jpg...............
  • avekevavekev UkPosts: 122MI6 Agent
    Do you think that Tom Ford might join the party and produce his own Madagascar shirt ;)
  • Asp9mmAsp9mm Over the Hills and Far Away.Posts: 7,535MI6 Agent
    avekev wrote:
    Do you think that Tom Ford might join the party and produce his own Madagascar shirt ;)

    Expect to pay $2900 for that.
    ..................Asp9mmSIG-1-2.jpg...............
  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    avekev wrote:
    Do you think that Tom Ford might join the party and produce his own Madagascar shirt ;)


    That is funny but not out of the relm of possibility.
  • Donald GrantDonald Grant U.S.A.Posts: 2,251Quartermasters
    edited October 2008
    Yeah, I actually got an e-mail from Magnoli last night about his Madagascar shirt, but resolved not to post about it here so as not to spoil Paul's deal. I too will honor my original promise to buy a shirt from Paul. I know some people will bow out, but to me being trustworthy is part of what makes a man a man. There is no question that Paul's shirt represents originality and will now be a display piece for me. However, I see Magnoli's shirt as a viable option for wearing.

    DG
    So, what sharp little eyes you've got...wait till you get to my teeth.
    image_zps6a725e59.jpg
    "People sleep peacefully in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf." Richard Grenier after George Orwell, Washington Times 1993.
  • Shatterhand67Shatterhand67 Safe HousePosts: 424MI6 Agent
    Obviously Magnoli is well respected but I don't think this should affect Paul's project at all. I think the people on the list wanted to get the exact shirt made with the exact pattern, exact material and by the exact same manufacturer.

    Magnoli does make fantastic products but when I had to choose between having the Turnbull & Asser tuxedo shirt or the Magnoli copy, I opted for the original. I remain committed to Paul's project and I expect that others previously committed will continue to do so.

    However, for people that missed the boat or were not comfortable with the price, Magnoli presents a new and exciting opportunity.

    Cheers!
    "I musht be dreaming."
  • Smithers500Smithers500 Spectre IslandPosts: 1,347MI6 Agent
    Well I'm fully paid up so happy to proceed with Paul's shirt.

    I've bought from Magnoli before and the quality has been generally excellent but "my word is my Bond", so as I'm fully paid up I'll proceed with Paul's shirt...
    Japanese proverb say, "Bird never make nest in bare tree".
  • InkedInked Posts: 61MI6 Agent
    The Magnoli shirt looks good, but it definitely doesn't line up as well as Pauls looks like it does. I'd say its worth a punt for those that can't stretch to the "real deal" but it certainly doesn't look like the same attention to detail has been applied (the placket is not lined up at all)
  • A7ceA7ce Birmingham, EnglandPosts: 656MI6 Agent
    Inked wrote:
    but it certainly doesn't look like the same attention to detail has been applied (the placket is not lined up at all)

    If I remember correctly these details were not aligned on the other shirt until someone pointed them out ie yoke, placket, pocket.
  • TALLMANTALLMAN Cornwall, United KingdomPosts: 69MI6 Agent
    Wow just seen the magnoli version too. Stll prefer you guys version but the price is going to be very tempting for some.
  • KittlemeierKittlemeier U.S.Posts: 432MI6 Agent
    The fabric is reversed. The hash marks should go from the left shoulder down to the right waist. Hopefully the fabric is double sided because the real stuff isn't.

    Other than that and the other mentioned things, it looks pretty good. I'm still getting the other one and $150 is still a lot but it'll be nice to know if it gets ripped on a nail or somthing, you can get a replacement, unlike the other project.
  • cpoulos62cpoulos62 Station UPosts: 451MI6 Agent
    Kittlemeier wrote:
    The fabric is reversed. The hash marks should go from the left shoulder down to the right waist. Hopefully the fabric is double sided because the real stuff isn't.

    Other than that and the other mentioned things, it looks pretty good. I'm still getting the other one and $150 is still a lot but it'll be nice to know if it gets ripped on a nail or somthing, you can get a replacement, unlike the other project.

    I would not be surprised if you would send a quick email to Magnoli, he would be able to address. I am sure that he has pride in his workmanship and would take the needed corrections seriously.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Copyright ajb007.co.uk 1998 - 2024

James Bond TM 007 and related James Bond Trademarks © 1962-2024

Danjaq LLC and United Artists Corporation. All Rights Reserved.

This website is a fan site and is in no way related to the official production companies.

All users are responsible for the content of their posts, by using this website you agree to the terms of use.