Loeffelhotz and Barbel, I could be mistaken, so forgive me if I am, but I believe that you've gone more than twice in the past two days.
Not guilty (I just checked). I usually post shortly after midnight GMT (though a couple of nights ago I did come home late from a particularly tiring gig and couldn't be bothered, so posted the next morning), and Loeffelholz posts a while after me- he's commented that my post acts as his cue that he can safely post now. It's probably just a timezone thing, Dan, we're from all over the world on this very wonderful site.
Sir MilesThe Wrong Side Of The WardrobePosts: 27,920Chief of Staff
Dr No [4]
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [28] -1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25]
Casino Royale [18] +1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [4]
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [27] -1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25]
Casino Royale [19] +1 = [20]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"A dry martini, in a deep champagne goblet. Three measures of Gordons, one of Vodka, half a measure of Kina Lillet. Shake it very well until its ice cold, then add a large thin slice of lemon peel. Got it?" - Ian Fleming's 'Casino Royale'
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
Dr No [4]
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [26] On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25] + 1 = [26] Casino Royale [20] - 1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [4]
From Russia With Love [37] +1= [38]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26]
Casino Royale [19] - 1 = [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Sweepy the CatHalifax, West Yorkshire, EnglaPosts: 986MI6 Agent
Dr No [4] - 1 = [3]
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] Casino Royale [18] + 1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [3] - 1 = [2]
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26] On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [2]
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26] + 1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [19] - 1 = [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [2] -1 = [1]
From Russia With Love [38]+1 = [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [1]+[1]=[2] (just had to do it... who could be so cruel?)
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [18]-[1]=[17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [1]+[1]=[2] (just had to do it... who could be so cruel?)
Oh come on!
"I never joke about my work 007"
LoeffelholzThe United States, With LovePosts: 8,998Quartermasters
edited June 2009
Dr No [2] + 1 = [3]
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27] On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] - 1 = [26]
Casino Royale [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Only delaying the inevitable, sadly...DN is a seminal classic that's not getting its dues here...ought to be a top three finisher, at least (it's 2nd on my own personal list)...guess a top five is still respectable---but not respectable enough
I'm leaving on a camping/fishing holiday tomorrow, for four days and three nights, so any further manufactured controversies will have to commence without me! ) Adieu, DN...you'll be gone when I return -{
Check out my Amazon author page!Mark Loeffelholz
"I am not an entrant in the Shakespeare Stakes." - Ian Fleming
"Screw 'em." - Daniel Craig, The Best James Bond EverTM
A movie that I think should be in the top three isn't going to make it either, and a movie that I think should have been out five places ago will be instead.... That's how it works....
"A dry martini, in a deep champagne goblet. Three measures of Gordons, one of Vodka, half a measure of Kina Lillet. Shake it very well until its ice cold, then add a large thin slice of lemon peel. Got it?" - Ian Fleming's 'Casino Royale'
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
LoeffelholzThe United States, With LovePosts: 8,998Quartermasters
edited June 2009
Yes, I realize that, actually---otherwise, OP and AVTAK would be squarely where they belong: at 21 and 22, respectively. My commentary on the proceedings has been limited, in all fairness, so I'm merely editorializing a bit. Here at the end of the game, the stakes get higher---as does the entertainment value B-) I'll just go camping and fishing, then...
[P.S. Not a vote!!]
Check out my Amazon author page!Mark Loeffelholz
"I am not an entrant in the Shakespeare Stakes." - Ian Fleming
"Screw 'em." - Daniel Craig, The Best James Bond EverTM
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25] +1=26
Casino Royale[23] -1 = [22]
This is tough, but I have to go with OHMSS for Peter Hunt.
Welcome, I like you already.
Thanks. Not many admire PH as much as I do. He is one of the true heroes of the series (along with Terrence Young, Ken Adam, John Barry, John Stears, etc.) Plus, CR is an easy target for me.
Dr No [3]
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Had to do it. For me it would always come down to OHMSS and FRWL. (although LALD is my childhood favorite.) CR just doesn't belong with any of the classics. Dr. No is fantastic, but too bogged down with starting everything off and is a bit too low-key thriller. Yet it has some of the touches that set it apart-Bond setting up Miss Taro's cottage for Dent's arrival. FRWL has the fast intrigue that makes it irresistible. Goldfinger just seems too full of what Bond would call the "soft life". (Goldfinger Ch. 1 of all places!) Plus I much prefer Terrence Young to Guy Hamilton's laid back approach. The first six films have the rapid fire cutting of Peter Hunt who directed OHMSS with his expertise gained over 7 years. Thus I give the edge to OHMSS.
Dr No [3] - 1 = [2]
From Russia With Love [39] + 1 = [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [2]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27] On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] - 1 = [26] Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dan, I'm sorry, not sure what happened with GF last time. I guess something went wrong with posting.
Dr No [2]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [2]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27] - 1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"A dry martini, in a deep champagne goblet. Three measures of Gordons, one of Vodka, half a measure of Kina Lillet. Shake it very well until its ice cold, then add a large thin slice of lemon peel. Got it?" - Ian Fleming's 'Casino Royale'
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
Dr No [2] - 1 = [1]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [26] On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] + 1 = [28]
Casino Royale [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dr No [1]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [26] +1= [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] -1= [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
I love DN to bits, and while I think it should have finished fourth (after GF, FRWL and TB) I'm not going to save it. I do think that it is a tragedy that it will have finished lower than the vastly inferior CR, and I also prefer it to OHMSS, but it's facing death and saving it will put off the inevitable for only so long.
"He’s a man way out there in the blue, riding on a smile and a shoeshine. And when they start not smiling back—that’s an earthquake. and then you get yourself a couple of spots on your hat, and you’re finished. Nobody dast blame this man. A salesman is got to dream, boy. It comes with the territory." Death of a Salesman
Sweepy the CatHalifax, West Yorkshire, EnglaPosts: 986MI6 Agent
Dr No [1] - 1 = [0]
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28] Casino Royale [16] + 1= [17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Sir MilesThe Wrong Side Of The WardrobePosts: 27,920Chief of Staff
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27] -1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] +1= [18]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [26]+[1]=[27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [18]-[1]=[17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27] +1 = [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] - 1= [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
While I love each of these Bond films, I believe CR has to go next, then OHMSS and GF can battle it out for 2nd and 3rd.
From Russia With Love [40] + 1 = [41]
Goldfinger [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [16] - 1 = [15]
Oh yes, would anyone object to me starting a villain elimination game (several days after this one is completed of course)? 28 villains are included (Including the five separate incarnations of Blofeld) If accepted, I'd get more into this later on, after this game is complete (Which hopefully will be within the next 3 weeks).
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [41]
Goldfinger [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28] - 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [15] + 1 = [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
And Felix, a villain elimination game sounds like fun.
Except for Goldfinger being there, three of the bests are left. What Goldfinger is doing here, I don't know....
From Russia With Love [41]
Goldfinger [28] - 1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"A dry martini, in a deep champagne goblet. Three measures of Gordons, one of Vodka, half a measure of Kina Lillet. Shake it very well until its ice cold, then add a large thin slice of lemon peel. Got it?" - Ian Fleming's 'Casino Royale'
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
From Russia With Love [41]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] + 1 = [28]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Comments
Not guilty (I just checked). I usually post shortly after midnight GMT (though a couple of nights ago I did come home late from a particularly tiring gig and couldn't be bothered, so posted the next morning), and Loeffelholz posts a while after me- he's commented that my post acts as his cue that he can safely post now. It's probably just a timezone thing, Dan, we're from all over the world on this very wonderful site.
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [28] -1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25]
Casino Royale [18] +1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [27] -1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25]
Casino Royale [19] +1 = [20]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
From Russia With Love [37]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [25] + 1 = [26]
Casino Royale [20] - 1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [37] +1= [38]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26]
Casino Royale [19] - 1 = [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
1 - Moore, 2 - Dalton, 3 - Craig, 4 - Connery, 5 - Brosnan, 6 - Lazenby
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26]
Casino Royale [18] + 1 = [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [19]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [38]
Goldfinger [26] + 1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [19] - 1 = [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [38]+1 = [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [18]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live and Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man with the Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [18]-[1]=[17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Oh come on!
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] - 1 = [26]
Casino Royale [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Only delaying the inevitable, sadly...DN is a seminal classic that's not getting its dues here...ought to be a top three finisher, at least (it's 2nd on my own personal list)...guess a top five is still respectable---but not respectable enough
I'm leaving on a camping/fishing holiday tomorrow, for four days and three nights, so any further manufactured controversies will have to commence without me!
"I am not an entrant in the Shakespeare Stakes." - Ian Fleming
"Screw 'em." - Daniel Craig, The Best James Bond EverTM
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
[P.S. Not a vote!!]
"I am not an entrant in the Shakespeare Stakes." - Ian Fleming
"Screw 'em." - Daniel Craig, The Best James Bond EverTM
From Russia With Love [39]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Had to do it. For me it would always come down to OHMSS and FRWL. (although LALD is my childhood favorite.) CR just doesn't belong with any of the classics. Dr. No is fantastic, but too bogged down with starting everything off and is a bit too low-key thriller. Yet it has some of the touches that set it apart-Bond setting up Miss Taro's cottage for Dent's arrival. FRWL has the fast intrigue that makes it irresistible. Goldfinger just seems too full of what Bond would call the "soft life". (Goldfinger Ch. 1 of all places!) Plus I much prefer Terrence Young to Guy Hamilton's laid back approach. The first six films have the rapid fire cutting of Peter Hunt who directed OHMSS with his expertise gained over 7 years. Thus I give the edge to OHMSS.
Dr No [3] - 1 = [2]
From Russia With Love [39] + 1 = [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] - 1 = [26]
Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Dan, I'm sorry, not sure what happened with GF last time. I guess something went wrong with posting.
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27] - 1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [26] + 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] + 1 = [28]
Casino Royale [17]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [26] +1= [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] -1= [16]
Eliminated
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
I love DN to bits, and while I think it should have finished fourth (after GF, FRWL and TB) I'm not going to save it. I do think that it is a tragedy that it will have finished lower than the vastly inferior CR, and I also prefer it to OHMSS, but it's facing death and saving it will put off the inevitable for only so long.
From Russia With Love [40]
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [16] + 1= [17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Goldfinger [27] -1 = [26]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] +1= [18]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Goldfinger [26]+[1]=[27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [18]-[1]=[17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Goldfinger [27] +1 = [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [17] - 1= [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
From Russia With Love [40] + 1 = [41]
Goldfinger [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28]
Casino Royale [16] - 1 = [15]
Oh yes, would anyone object to me starting a villain elimination game (several days after this one is completed of course)? 28 villains are included (Including the five separate incarnations of Blofeld) If accepted, I'd get more into this later on, after this game is complete (Which hopefully will be within the next 3 weeks).
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
Goldfinger [28]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [28] - 1 = [27]
Casino Royale [15] + 1 = [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
And Felix, a villain elimination game sounds like fun.
Any chance to disagree with Dan again... :v
From Russia With Love [41]
Goldfinger [28] - 1 = [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27]
Casino Royale [16] + 1 = [17]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day
"We're just too different... I mean, you're dead...." - Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride'
Goldfinger [27]
On Her Majesty's Secret Service [27] + 1 = [28]
Casino Royale [17] - 1 = [16]
Eliminated
5th - Dr No
6th - Quantum of Solace
7th - Thunderball
8th - The Living Daylights
9th - Goldeneye
10th - Licence To Kill
11th - The Spy Who Loved Me
12th - For Your Eyes Only
13th - You Only Live Twice
14th - Live And Let Die
15th - The World Is Not Enough
16th - Octopussy
17th - Diamonds Are Forever
18th - Tomorrow Never Dies
19th - The Man With The Golden Gun
20th - Moonraker
21st - A View To A Kill
22nd - Die Another Day