A Bit O' Maths

Jarvio

How does each bond actor’s era rank with you by following these particular rules?
- Give each bond film a mark out of 10
- Total up each film for each actor
- Divide the actor’s total by how many films the actor did, i.e. find the mean score
Here are the results for me:

1st - Timothy Dalton
Film scores – 9 (TLD), 10 (LTK)
Mean score - 9.5

2nd - Roger Moore
Film scores – 10 (LALD), 9 (TMWTGG), 9 (TSWLM), 8 (MR), 10 (FYEO), 10 (OP), 10 (AVTAK)
Mean score - 9.428

3rd - George Lazenby
Film score - 9 (OHMSS)
Mean score - 9

4th (Tie) - Sean Connery
Film scores – 9 (DN), 8 (FRWL), 7 (GF), 7 (TB), 8 (YOLT), 9 (DAF)
Mean score – 8

4th (Tie) - Daniel Craig
Film scores – 7 (CR), 7 (QOS), 10 (SF)
Mean score – 8

6th - Pierce Brosnan
Film scores – 9 (GE), 7 (TND), 7 (TWINE), 7 (DAD)
Mean score - 7.5

chrisisall

Tim & Laz tie with 9, Broz gets 8, Connery gets 7.9, Dan gets 7.6 & Rog gets 7.

chrisisall

This was kind of fun, and it shows me how fond I am of ALL the Bonds- a mere 2 pt. difference!

Bodie

Connery:

DN 8
FRWL 10
GF 10
TB 9
YOLT 8
DAF 4

Mean score: 8.1

Lazenby:

OHMSS 10

Mean score: 10

Moore

LALD 7
TMWTGG 6
TSWLM 9
MR 2
FYEO 8
OP 6
AVTAK 5

Mean score: 6.1

Dalton:

TLD 10
LTK 7

Mean Score: 8.5

Brosnan:

GE 10
TND 7
TWINE 8
DAD 6

Mean score: 7.75

Craig:

CR 10
QOS 5
SF 8

Mean score: 7.6

Interesting exercise. Connery is still my favourite.

chrisisall

Bodie wrote:

Interesting exercise. Connery is still my favourite.

Understandable.
Hey- our Craig scores are the same! Even though your faves are not mine... 8-)

Dutchfinger

Awesome idea!
I just used my overall ranking list of the movies and devided the list into these grades. (Top 5 movies score a 10) (Bottom 5 score from 5 to 4) etc...

Here goes:

1. Sean Connery:
DN 7
FRWL 8
GF 10
TB 8
YOLT 8
DAF 4
Mean Score: 7,5

2. George Lazenby
OHMSS 5

3. Roger Moore
LALD 5
TMWTGG 6
TSWLM 9
MR 6
FYEO 9
OP 7
AVTAK 5
Mean Score: 6,7

4. Timothy Dalton:
LTK 10
TLD 7
Mean Score: 8,5

5. Pierce Brosnan:
GE 10
TND 7
TWINE 7
DAD 5
Mean Score: 7,25

6. Daniel Craig
CR 10
Qos 4
SF 10
Mean Score: 8


Mean scores of the actors:
1. Timothy Dalton (8,5)
2. Daniel Craig (8)
3. Sean Connery (7,5) (Damn you DAF! :P )
4. Pierce Brosnan (7,25)
5. Roger Moore (6,7)
6. George Lazenby (5)

Very intersting idea! And it's funny because I personally would have ranked the Bond's a slightly different. But I guess it does give an accurate display here! Connery is my favorite, but DAF really brought his mean score down :P - I'm happy for Dalton that he made my top place though, I think he will get some sweet deals in this thread )

chrisisall wrote:

Tim & Laz tie with 9

Suprised to see Dalton didn't get a perfect 10 in your case. Seeing as both of his movies are at the top spot of your ranking! Haha

chrisisall

Dutchfinger wrote:

2. George Lazenby
OHMSS 5

Wow, you don't like this move much, eh? It's not my fave by a long shot, but I can recognize its brilliance.

chrisisall wrote:

Tim & Laz tie with 9

Dutchfinger wrote:

Surprised to see Dalton didn't get a perfect 10 in your case. Seeing as both of his movies are at the top spot of your ranking! Haha

They ARE my faves, but neither are perfect. I gave the highest ranking (9.5) to FRWL.

Dutchfinger

chrisisall wrote:

Dutchfinger wrote:

2. George Lazenby
OHMSS 5

Wow, you don't like this move much, eh? It's not my fave by a long shot, but I can recognize its brilliance.

Yeah I'm still in desperate hoping to like it more someday though. I feel like the most controversial 'diehard' Bond fan for ranking a movie that is arguably the best adaptation of a Fleming novel so low. But I can't help it, there's just a lot I don't like about it. I am working on a video review in which I explain exactly how I feel about the whole film to give that statement a bit more validity..

chrisisall wrote:

chrisisall wrote:

Tim & Laz tie with 9

Dutchfinger wrote:

Surprised to see Dalton didn't get a perfect 10 in your case. Seeing as both of his movies are at the top spot of your ranking! Haha

They ARE my faves, but neither are perfect. I gave the highest ranking (9.5) to FRWL.

Fair enough! Wonder if SPECTRE has the potential to be the first movie you would grant a perfect 10!

chrisisall

Dutchfinger wrote:

Yeah I'm still in desperate hoping to like it more someday though. I feel like the most controversial 'diehard' Bond fan for ranking a movie that is arguably the best adaptation of a Fleming novel so low. But I can't help it, there's just a lot I don't like about it. I am working on a video review in which I explain exactly how I feel about the whole film to give that statement a bit more validity..

Actually I enjoy DN & GF more, but FRWL is technically a much better made film.

Sadly, no Bond seems to break into my perfect 10... that's Blade Runner terrain.....

Dutchfinger

chrisisall wrote:

Actually I enjoy DN & GF more, but FRWL is technically a much better made film.

I won't deny that OHMSS isn't technically a good film either (Great cinematography etc). But I guess to me it goes to show that Novel Bond is very different to Cinematic Bond and the pages don't necessarily always translate into the best movies for me. FRWL was one of my personal best reads ever, but it is not my favorite Bond movie because of that. FRWL as a movie has it's dated moments like the Bond theme playing even if Bond is just tipping the doorman, or the rear projections in the canals of Venice and Bond throwing the film in the water and waving it goodbye. Just minor things, of course, FRWL is a movie I rank high nonetheless!

But OHMSS to me has a lot more problems, despite being based on a novel that is regarded high among fans.

Matt S

1st - George Lazenby
Film score - 10 (OHMSS)
Mean score - 10

2nd - Roger Moore
Film scores – 8 (LALD), 7 (TMWTGG), 8 (TSWLM), 8 (MR), 10 (FYEO), 9 (OP), 6 (AVTAK)
Mean score - 8

3rd - Sean Connery
Film scores – 7 (DN), 10 (FRWL), 7 (GF), 7 (TB), 9 (YOLT), 6 (DAF)
Mean score – 7.66

4th - Timothy Dalton
Film scores – 10 (TLD), 5 (LTK)
Mean score - 7.5

5th - Daniel Craig
Film scores – 6 (CR), 5 (QOS), 7 (SF)
Mean score – 6

6th - Pierce Brosnan
Film scores – 5 (GE), 5 (TND), 7 (TWINE), 5 (DAD)
Mean score - 5.5

This doesn't correspond to how much I like each Bond actor, but it's not totally off either.

Firemass

This is the kinda post that makes me love being a Bond fan

DN 10
FRWL 8
GF 10
TB 5
YOLT 7
DAF 7
NSNA 8

7.86 for Sean

OHMSS 7 for George

LALD 7
TMWTGG 7.5
TSWLM 10
MR 10
FYEO 6
OP 8
AVTAK 9

8.21 for Roger

TLD 8.5
LTK 8.5

8.5 for Tim

GE 9.5
TND 9
TWINE 9
DAD 6

8.375 for Pierce

CR 7
QoS 8
SF 3

6 for Dan

Dutchfinger

Firemass wrote:

QoS 8
SF 3

Our worlds could not be farther apart on this one! ) But I guess that's the beauty of Bond fandom! -{
(Why is SF the worst in the series in your opinion though? )

Bondage007

I'll go by what I've seen in my Bondathon so far. This is by enjoyment, and is a relative ranking, so the numbers will change as I watch more films

DN 10
FRWL 10
GF 7
TB 4
YOLT 6
OHMSS 10
DAF 8

Connery 7.7
Lazenby 10

Jarvio

chrisisall wrote:

Sadly, no Bond seems to break into my perfect 10... that's Blade Runner terrain.....

Some bond films are a 10 for me, but I agree about Blade Runner, what a great movie!

Thunderpussy

My 10 would be The Marx Bros " Duck Soup" ......... That's soup tureen..... {:)

chrisisall

Jarvio wrote:

chrisisall wrote:

Sadly, no Bond seems to break into my perfect 10... that's Blade Runner terrain.....

Some bond films are a 10 for me, but I agree about Blade Runner, what a great movie!

The series is a definite 10+, it's just that no single film in it is my definition of an absolute masterpiece for me (FRWL comes closest).

Barbel

Thunderpussy wrote:

My 10 would be The Marx Bros " Duck Soup" ......... That's soup tureen..... {:)

Wonderful film! {[] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKTT-sy0aLg

chrisisall

Barbel wrote:

Thunderpussy wrote:

My 10 would be The Marx Bros " Duck Soup" ......... That's soup tureen..... {:)

Wonderful film! {[] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKTT-sy0aLg

Great movie, but not quite a 10 to me... only comedy I'd rate 10 would be Dr. Strangelove... or... maybe Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey.

MooseWithFleas

Connery
DN: 9
FRWL: 10
GF: 8
TB: 9
YOLT: 7
DAF: 5

Connery Average: 8.0

Lazenby
OHMSS: 9 9.0

Lazenby Average: 9.0

Moore
LALD: 10
TMWTGG: 8
TSWLM: 10
MR: 10
FYEO: 8
OP: 9
AVTAK: 8

Moore Average: 9

Dalton
TLD: 10
LTK: 8

Dalton Average: 9

Brosnan
GE: 9
TND: 7
TWINE: 4
DAD: 5

Brosnan Average: 6.25

Craig
CR: 10
QoS: 5
SF: 10

Craig Average: 8.33





Very interesting as this is not how I would rank the Bond actors!

Absolutely_Cart

Why not?

Connery - 7.5
DN - 9
FRWL - 8
GF - 10
TB - 7
YOLT - 7
DAF - 4

Lazenby - N/A
OHMSS - 9

Moore - 6.6
LALD - 8
TMWTGG - 4
TSWLM - 9
MR - 5
FYEO - 7
OP - 8
AVTAK - 5

Dalton - 7
TLD - 7
LTK - 7

Brosnan - 6
GE - 7
TND - 6
TWINE - 7
DAD - 4

Craig - 7.6
CR06 - 10
QOS - 6
SF - 7

DutchJamesBondFan

XX - (Movie) // (Actor)

Connery - 7.3 //7.5
DN - 7 // 8
FRWL - 9 // 9
GF - 9 // 9
TB - 6 // 7
YOLT - 6 // 6
DAF - 7 // 6

Lazenby - 9 // 7
OHMSS - 9 // 7

Moore - 7.1 // 7.2
LALD - 6 // 7
TMWTGG - 7 // 8
TSWLM - 8 // 8
MR - 7 // 7
FYEO - 8 // 7
OP - 7 // 7
AVTAK - 7 // 7

Dalton - 9
TLD - 7 // 8
LTK - 9 // 10

Brosnan - 7.8 // 8.5
GE - 9 // 9
TND - 8 // 9
TWINE - 7 // 8
DAD - 7 // 8

Craig - 7.6 // 9
CR - 9 // 10
QOS - 7 // 9
SF - 7 // 8

BIG TAM

Sean Connery:
Dr. No = 9
From Russia With Love = 9
Goldfinger = 9
Thunderball = 8
You Only Live Twice = 7
Diamonds Are Forever = 8 = 50 / 6 = 8.3

George Lazenby:
On Her Majesty’s Secret Service = 9 / 1 = 9

Roger Moore:
Live & Let Die = 9
The Man With The Golden Gun = 7
The Spy Who Loved Me = 9
Moonraker = 7
For Your Eyes Only = 8
Octopussy = 8
A View To A Kill = 6 = 54 / 7 = 7.7

Timothy Dalton:
The Living Daylights = 8
Licence To Kill = 9 = 17 / 2 = 8.5

Pierce Brosnan:
GoldenEye = 8
Tomorrow Never Dies = 8
The World Is Not Enough = 8
Die Another Day = 7 = 31 / 4 = 7.8

Daniel Craig:
Casino Royale = 9
Quantum Of Solace = 8
Skyfall = 9 = 26 / 3 = 8.7

In summary:-
1. George Lazenby = 9
2. Daniel Craig = 8.7
3. Timothy Dalton = 8.5
4. Sean Connery = 8.3
5. Pierce Brosnan = 7.8
6. Roger Moore = 7.7

MilleniumForce

Connery:

Dr No - 6
From Russia With Love - 7
Goldfinger - 10
Thunderball - 5
You Only Live Twice - 7
Diamonds Are Forever - 8
Never Say Never Again - 7

Niven:
Casino Royale - 1

Lazenby:
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 6

Moore:
Live And Let Die - 8
The Man With The Golen Gun - 8
The Spy Who Loved Me - 8
Moonraker - 9
For Your Eyes Only - 9
Octopussy - 10
A View to a Kill - 9

Dalton:
The Living Daylights - 8
Licence to Kill - 10

Brosnan:
GoldenEye - 10
Tomorrow Never Dies - 9
The World is Not Enough - 7
Die Another Day - 7

Craig:
Casino Royale - 7
Quantum of Solace - 7
Skyfall - 10



Connery - 7.1
Niven - 1
Lazenby - 6
Moore - 8.7
Dalton - 9
Brosnan - 8.5
Craig - 8

eric7064

Very cool idea. Will add mine today!

eric7064

Connery Era:
DN- 8.5
FRWL- 9
GF- 10
TB- 8.5
YOLT- 7.5
DAF- 7

Final Rating : 8.41

Lazenby Era:
OHMSS- 10

Final Rating: 10 (Movie was much better then actor)

Final Rating:

Moore Era:
LALD- 9
TMWTGG- 6
TSWLM- 8
MR- 9
FYEO- 7
OP-6
AVTAK- 5

Final Rating: 7.14

Dalton Era:

TLD- 7.5
LTK-9

Final Rating: 8.25

Brosnan Era:
GE- 10
TND- 8
DAD- 7.5
TWINE- 7

Final Rating: 8.125

Craig Era:
CR- 10
QOS- 8
SF- 9.5

Final Rating: 9.16

eric7064

Updated with craig. Definitely a fun test.