who bought the John Smedley SF Sweater ? Sizing inquiry here

thinking about getting the John Smedley Black Bobby V Neck Sweater...

im 160 LBs with 38 inch chest.

looking for a fitted look.

Normally, i would go with Small.

but I hear the sweater runs small and I should get a Medium.

Any advice would be appreciated

Comments

  • redsleighdownredsleighdown USAPosts: 450MI6 Agent
    I'm your stats and got a small. Definitely fitted. Not too tight, but a medium should still be fitted. What's your height? I'm 5'10 and didn't want it any longer in the waist.
  • Double0zeroDouble0zero Los AngelesPosts: 220MI6 Agent
    iam 5'10 as well :)

    do you feel you have room in the S just in case you gain a little weight or wash it more often ?

    or is it just too perfectly fitted with no room for more ???

    im torn !!! ?:)
  • BlueBludBlueBlud Posts: 255MI6 Agent
    I would go for the small. I have a 42-43 inch chest and the medium fits perfect on me. I don't think it would be very fitted on you.
  • Hold CommandHold Command LondonPosts: 376MI6 Agent
    iam 5'10 as well :)

    do you feel you have room in the S just in case you gain a little weight or wash it more often ?

    or is it just too perfectly fitted with no room for more ???

    im torn !!! ?:)

    These will not shrink if you follow the instructions, HAND WASH ONLY!
  • don pdon p Posts: 607MI6 Agent
    im a 42, 5.11 tall, and bought an M,, ide like it to be a little larger as it is very fitted, so go with an S

    Don,,
  • jared_nomakjared_nomak Posts: 1,944MI6 Agent
    thinking about getting the John Smedley Black Bobby V Neck Sweater...

    im 160 LBs with 38 inch chest.

    looking for a fitted look.

    Normally, i would go with Small.

    but I hear the sweater runs small and I should get a Medium.

    Any advice would be appreciated

    I'm a 38/39 chest and went for a small too
    Ross
  • Double0zeroDouble0zero Los AngelesPosts: 220MI6 Agent
    thank you all !! :)
  • Batman007Batman007 Posts: 40MI6 Agent
    Bumping this.

    I have a 37" chest and I am wondering if I should go with a XS or a S. What do you guys think?
  • JMac88JMac88 Posts: 281MI6 Agent
    Batman007 wrote:
    Bumping this.

    I have a 37" chest and I am wondering if I should go with a XS or a S. What do you guys think?

    How tall are you? I'd probably go with an XS if I were you. I'm 5'9.5, 42" chest with an athletic build and I fit into the small-size pretty easily. Depends on what you want to do with it though, as I also have a medium-size one to wear over top of a dress shirt. The small is just for wearing by itself as it's tight (I like the snug feel :p ).
  • SkylndSkylnd CanadaPosts: 28MI6 Agent
    I'm 140 lbs, 5'10 height and I went with a small.
  • Batman007Batman007 Posts: 40MI6 Agent
    JMac88 wrote:
    Batman007 wrote:
    Bumping this.

    I have a 37" chest and I am wondering if I should go with a XS or a S. What do you guys think?

    How tall are you? I'd probably go with an XS if I were you. I'm 5'9.5, 42" chest with an athletic build and I fit into the small-size pretty easily. Depends on what you want to do with it though, as I also have a medium-size one to wear over top of a dress shirt. The small is just for wearing by itself as it's tight (I like the snug feel :p ).
    I am 5'7" with a 37" chest and 18-18.5" shoulders, also 145lbs. I can go between smalls or mediums depending on the brand because of my shoulders.

    Still think I should get the X-Small? I keep reading it's a fitted sweater and I feel like if I bought a X-Small it would be like stuffing a sausage. I am very well muscled for my height so I don't want to have it look like I spray painted it on.
  • JMac88JMac88 Posts: 281MI6 Agent
    Batman007 wrote:
    JMac88 wrote:
    Batman007 wrote:
    Bumping this.

    I have a 37" chest and I am wondering if I should go with a XS or a S. What do you guys think?

    How tall are you? I'd probably go with an XS if I were you. I'm 5'9.5, 42" chest with an athletic build and I fit into the small-size pretty easily. Depends on what you want to do with it though, as I also have a medium-size one to wear over top of a dress shirt. The small is just for wearing by itself as it's tight (I like the snug feel :p ).
    I am 5'7" with a 37" chest and 18-18.5" shoulders, also 145lbs. I can go between smalls or mediums depending on the brand because of my shoulders.

    Still think I should get the X-Small? I keep reading it's a fitted sweater and I feel like if I bought a X-Small it would be like stuffing a sausage. I am very well muscled for my height so I don't want to have it look like I spray painted it on.

    Hmm, given those dimensions I think you could really go either way. If you want a skin-tight fit, go with the XS. If you want something fitted that could still have room for a dress shirt underneath (like the Daniel Craig look), go with the S.

    It was actually cool enough where I live on Monday that I got to wear my small-sized Bobby. It was awesome, but I'm glad I have the medium for layering purposes.
  • Batman007Batman007 Posts: 40MI6 Agent
    Definitely going with the small, especially due to inevitable washing it shall receive.
Sign In or Register to comment.